It’s Still All About the Value Proposition
The Constant Truth in a World of Exponential Change
(This is an overhaul of an old post)
In 2003, Steve Jobs took the stage and changed the music industry forever with just seven words: "1,000 songs fit right in my pocket." With this simple yet powerful statement, he conveyed the iPod’s value proposition in a way that was instantly clear to consumers. Music lovers no longer needed to carry bulky CD cases, create cumbersome mixtapes, or buy entire albums just to get one hit song. Instead, their entire music collection became portable, accessible, and effortlessly convenient.
Jobs didn’t list the features of the iPod. He didn’t talk about its storage capacity, battery life, or user interface. Instead, he painted a picture of how life would change for the consumer. This is the essence of a great Value Proposition— it tells customers what problem they no longer need to face and explains why a product is the best solution.
Why a Strong Value Proposition Matters More Than Ever
In an era of rapid technological advancement, understanding and articulating a strong value proposition is more important than ever. Emerging technologies like AI, blockchain, and 3D printing introduce revolutionary changes, but their success depends on how effectively they address real customer problems. Too often, product teams fall into the trap of applying an emerging technology to an existing product or building a completely new product based on the technology without considering whether it truly solves a customer problem.
Juicero was a $400 Wi-Fi-connected juicer designed to squeeze pre-packaged juice packs—except for one tiny problem: customers quickly discovered they could just squeeze the packs by hand with the same results. This was the business equivalent of designing a state-of-the-art robotic arm to butter toast when a regular knife does the job just as well. A masterpiece of over-engineering, like a voice-activated spoon or sneakers with minature jet engines, it ultimately proved one thing: sometimes, the simplest solution is the best—especially when your high-tech alternative loses a head-to-head battle with basic human fingers.
Kodak, once the king of photography, attempted to make a comeback in 2016 with the Kodak Ektra Smartphone—a device that slapped its legendary camera branding onto a smartphone to attract photography enthusiasts. However, instead of revolutionizing mobile photography, it flopped spectacularly; the camera wasn’t genuinely good, the software was clunky, and at $550, it competed against flagship smartphones that outperformed it in every task. To make matters worse, Kodak misread the market; people didn’t want a “camera-first” smartphone—they wanted a great smartphone that also featured an excellent camera.
By contrast to Juicero and the Ektra smartphone, the iPod is a classic example of solving a latent problem that consumers had accepted as part of life. Before its invention, people carried CD cases and spent hours creating mixed CDs because that was the norm. And before that? Mix tapes—the original love language of the ’80s and ’90s. If you truly liked someone, you would spend hours recording the perfect playlist onto a cassette, carefully timing each track while hoping that your tape deck didn’t eat your masterpiece. It was a labor of love (and sometimes heartbreak, depending on the recipient’s reaction). Nobody was explicitly asking for an iPod because they didn’t realize a better solution was possible. When Apple introduced the iPod, it didn’t just solve an inconvenience; it redefined how people consumed music. Moreover, the iPod’s success was not merely about the device itself but about the business model shift that came with iTunes. By allowing users to buy and download individual songs instead of entire albums, Apple transformed the entire music industry.
The Customer Value Proposition Equation
A Customer Value Proposition can be understood as a simple function:
CVP = f(CP1) + f(CP2) + f(CP3)
Where:
CVP = Customer Value Proposition
CP = Customer Problem
In other words, when a company clearly identifies customer problems, it becomes much easier to articulate a compelling value proposition. However, many product teams overlook this step. Instead of basing their work on genuine customer needs, they create products from mere “good ideas,” hoping that marketing and sales teams will drive adoption. This strategy is a recipe for failure—a fancy way of saying they’re rolling the dice and hoping for the jackpot. And when the product inevitably fails to gain traction, they don’t question the idea itself—they blame marketing and sales for not ‘selling it hard enough.’
A product or service doesn’t need to exist before defining its value proposition. A strong value proposition starts with a deep understanding of the customer’s problems, desires, and behaviors. I personally initiate the product development process by defining the value proposition. This becomes my commitment to the customer and my guiding principle throughout product development. To build on this, we should consider the job-to-be-done: What is the customer truly trying to accomplish? What obstacles hinder their progress?
By framing these insights in a needs statement or job story, product teams can precisely define the problem and align their innovations with real customer pain points. An effective needs statement includes:
The customer
Their need or desire
The context in which they must achieve it
The outcome they seek
With validated needs statements and a well-articulated Customer Value Proposition, product teams can experiment with various solutions and technologies to discover how to best deliver on their promise.
Why Most Value Propositions Fail
Value propositions are often an afterthought—a catchy marketing slogan added after the product is developed. This leads companies to depend on flashy language rather than authentic problem-solving. When marketing and sales teams struggle to articulate a product’s value, it usually signifies that the product team didn't fully understand the customer’s problem from the start. A Customer Value Proposition based on real customer problems can serve as a powerful marketing tool, but it should arise from thoroughly discovered and validated problems—not be crafted solely for marketing purposes.
The best approach is to create a customer-needs roadmap rather than a product-features roadmap. This enables product teams to iteratively address one validated customer need at a time, ensuring that the product stays relevant and valuable. The process is not complete until the customer explicitly confirms that the product solves their problem more effectively than any available alternative.
The Business Side of the Value Proposition
While the Customer Value Proposition is critical in addressing a customer problem, and the problem itself may be very real, that doesn’t automatically mean the company in question is the best one to solve it. A Value Proposition is not just about customers—it must also implicitly or explicitly express how the business captures value from solving the problem. A great Value Proposition satisfies two key conditions:
It solves a meaningful customer problem
It does so in a way that is financially sustainable
Businesses that focus solely on solving customer problems without considering profitability struggle to scale. Conversely, companies that prioritize profitability over genuine customer value quickly become irrelevant. To reflect this, our Value Proposition equation should include business viability:
VP = [f(CP1) + f(CP2) + f(CP3)] - C(TC) + R(BR)
Where:
C(TC) = Cost function of Total Costs (operational, acquisition, and delivery costs)
R(BR) = Returns as a function of Business Results (profitability, market expansion, brand equity, etc.)
A business that gets this equation right creates a self-reinforcing cycle of customer value and enterprise success. And thsoe that proactively manage to these fundamental fubctions, don’t just survive; they thrive.
Case Study: Uber’s Value Proposition
Consider Uber’s simple but powerful Value Proposition: “Tap the app, get a ride.”
From the customer’s perspective, this eliminates the hassles of hailing a cab, negotiating fares, or dealing with cash. But Uber’s success wasn’t just about solving customer problems—it was about doing so profitably.
Uber’s business model includes:
Dynamic pricing for profitability
AI-driven demand forecasting for efficiency
Minimized driver acquisition costs
If Uber had simply built a ride-sharing platform without a sustainable business model*, it would have failed—even if customers loved the product.
Managing to the Value Proposition: A First-Principles Approach
Focusing on the value proposition allows businesses to solve the fundamental customer problem while also achieving company objectives. This approach is like cooking from scratch rather than just pouring store-bought sauce over last night's leftovers. First-principles thinking—analyzing challenges down to their core elements—prevents product teams from getting sidetracked by flashy trends and instead keeps the focus on what truly matters.
When product teams focus on the value proposition, they concentrate on effectively and sustainably meeting a genuine, urgent customer need. Rather than chasing the latest buzzword, they ask and seek to uncover, "What does our customer truly need?" “What is the fundamental truth about the problem they face?” and “How can we address it in a financially viable way?" This approach ensures that every decision, from product development to marketing, is not simply a game of corporate improv but a calculated strategy grounded in delivering authentic customer value (i.e., fundamental problems customers aim to solve) while meeting corporate goals.
A Simple Test for a Strong Value Proposition
To evaluate a Value Proposition, ask two questions:
Does it solve a high-value proven problem for the customer?
Can the business deliver this solution profitably and sustainably?
If the answer to both is yes, you're on the right track. If not, either the problem isn’t significant enough or the business model needs adjusting.
Final Thoughts: The Continuous Evolution of Value Propositions
By managing to the value proposition, product teams can remain agile and responsive in an era of rapid change. Instead of being caught off guard by disruption, they cultivate the ability to sense and adjust to both emerging and hidden customer problems. This mindset ensures they are not merely reacting to change but actively using it to their advantage.
Teams attuned to real customer needs will be much better positioned to leverage new technologies to solve previously intractable problems or address emerging challenges brought about by technological advancements. Instead of hastily attaching AI, blockchain, or the latest buzzword to an existing product, they can thoughtfully integrate innovation only where it truly enhances value. Similarly, by focusing on customer issues rather than becoming enamored with their own products, they remain open to necessary pivots, avoiding the fate of companies that clung too tightly to outdated solutions while the market evolved around them.
A well-managed value proposition is not merely a statement—it’s a strategic compass. It ensures that businesses remain relevant, competitive, and prepared to meet the needs of a future that is always in flux. It is not a static declaration, either—it must evolve. Once a product reaches maturity, the value proposition requires continuous re-evaluation:
Are the original customer needs still valid?
Has the market changed?
Do new problems prevent customers from completing their job-to-be-done?
Are total costs increasing?
Is it getting more costly to acquire new customers?
Does the business value still make sense in terms of profitability, markt growth, brand equity?
A well-crafted value proposition doesn’t just sell a product—it creates demand, making adoption effortless. When Steve Jobs proclaimed, “1,000 songs in your pocket,” it required no explanation. The promise was straightforward, compelling, and transformative.
A compelling value proposition encourages customers to respond with, "Yes, this product understands my pain better than any other on the market." This statement forms the basis of both customer loyalty and business success.
---
Further Reading on Value Propositions:
Value Proposition Design – Alex Osterwalder, Yves Pigneur, Gregory Bernarda
Product Roadmaps Relaunched – C. Todd Lombardo, Bruce McCarthy, Evan Ryan, Michael Connors
Jobs to Be Done: A Roadmap for Customer-Centered Innovation – Stephen Wunker, Jessica Wattman, David Farber